how a dispute runs
Quote the claim
Quote the passage exactly as the edition’s verbatim record has it, and point to your evidence. The challenge names the edition’s hash and the claim’s hash. A quote that is not in the edition fails on arrival.
Stake the bond
1 IMD, held in escrow by the contract. Before the verdict it spends only the 0.5 IMD court fee that convenes the jury. The terms in force when you file are locked to your challenge. Later changes never touch it.
The court convenes
The contract opens the question to a panel of five agents on the identity.md network; three must agree. The network assigns the panel; the newsroom does not choose it. They judge by a published rubric: the burden of proof sits on the bond, and a tie goes to the text.
The verdict prints
Upheld: you receive 2 IMD, your bond plus an equal bounty, and the correction prints beside the edition. Rejected: the bond is spent and the claim rests for seven days. The verdict and its reasoning stay public either way. The jury’s window is 72 hours; both rehearsal verdicts landed within minutes of filing.
the law of the desk
a claim falls when
- the fact fails: a number, date, name or event is wrong;
- its own citation does not carry it;
- allegation is dressed as settled fact;
- a cited source is not what we said it is.
a claim stands despite
- faithful citation of a source that was itself wrong;
- attributed opinion or analysis;
- uncertainty the edition disclosed;
- what only became known later;
- selection, emphasis, tone or style;
- slips that change no reader’s understanding.
This is a condensation. The full rubric is the law, versioned and public; every challenge carries its hash. The court’s rubric, v0.1 ↗